скачать PDF
Authors : 1. Konstantin V. Kargin,
PhD (Law), associate professor
Nizhniy Novgorod law academy, Nizhniy Novgorod, Russia
Participants of juridical argumentation
Objective: To formulate the author’s definition of the notion “participants of juridical argumentation” and to view their composition.
Methods: The methodological basis of the research is general dialectical method of cognition, as well as the logical, systemic, comparative and other methods of scientific research.
Results: Basing on the carried out analysis of the composition of participants of juridical argumentation, the author has grounded the opinion of distinguishing the notion “participant of juridical argumentation” from “subject of juridical argumentation”, and of viewing the subject as one of the participants of juridical argumentation along with the addressee and other participants.
Scientific novelty: For the first time in juridical science the composition of participants of juridical argumentation is viewed, specific features characterizing the subject, addressee and other participants of juridical argumentation are revealed and analyzed.
Practical value: The theoretical provisions formulated in the research can be used in scientific, law-making and law enforcement activity, in educational process of higher professional educational institutions of juridical profile, in qualification improvement of scientific-educational personnel in the sphere of jurisprudence.
Keywords :
juridical argumentation; participants of juridical argumentation; subject of juridical argumentation; addressee of juridical argumentation; legal position; legal argument
Bibliography :
1. Ugolovno-protsessual'noe pravo Rossiiskoi Federatsii, otv. red. I.L. Petrukhin, I.B. Mikhailovskaya (Criminal-procedural law of the Russian Federation, executive editors I.L. Petrukhin, B. Mikhailovskaya), Moscow, 2011, 688 p.
2. Kartashov V.N. Yuridicheskaya deyatel'nost': problemy teorii i metodologii (Juridical activity: issues of theory and methodology), Moscow, 1990, 44 p.
3. Kartashov V.N. Yuridicheskaya deyatel'nost': ponyatie, struktura, tsennost' (Juridical activity: notion, structure, value). Saratov, 1989, 218 p.
4. Belyaev V.P. Kontrol' i nadzor v Rossiiskom gosudarstve (Control and observation in the Russian state), Moscow, 2005, 275 p.
5. Marchenko M.N.Obshchaya teoriya gosudarstva i prava. Akademicheskii kurs: v 3 t. (General theory of state and law. Academic course: in 3 vol.), Moscow, 2010, 712 p.
6. Zharova E.Yu. Programma kak pravovoi document (Program as legal document). Nizhnii Novgorod, 2008, 218 p.
7. Ozhegov S.I. Slovar' russkogo yazyka (The dictionary of Russian language), Moscow, 1964, 900 p.
8. Sovetskii entsiklopedicheskii slovar', gl. red. A.M. Prokhorova (Soviet encyclopedic dictionary, chief editor A.M. Prokhorova), Moscow, 1984, 1600 p.
9. Chueshov K.V. Argumentatsiya kak sredstvo sotsial'noi vostrebovannosti yuristov i ee logiko-lingvisticheskie aspekty (Argumentation as a means of social demand for lawyers and its logical-linguistic aspects), Problemy upravleniya, 2008, No. 2 (27), pp. 173–176.
10. Makeeva E.A. Pravovaya argumentatsiya kak ob"ekt gnoseologicheskogo analiza (Legal argumenttionas an object of gnosiological analysis), Moscow, 2003, 141 p.
11. Timofeev A.I. Argumentatsiya: teoriya i praktika (Argumentation: theory and practice), Saint Petersburg, 2005, 80 p.
12. Kirillov V.I., Starchenko A.A. Logika (Logic), Moscow, 2007, 256 p.
13. Mikhalkin N.V. Logika i argumentatsiya v sudebnoi praktike (Logic and argumentation in court practice), Saint Petersburg, 2004, 336 p.
14. Eemeren van Frans Kh., Grootendorst R. Rechevye akty v argumentativnykh diskussiyakh (Verbal acts in argumentative discussions), Saint Petersburg, 1994, 120 p.
15. Baranov V.M., Stepankov V.G. Pravovaya pozitsiya kak obshcheteoreticheskii fenomen (Legal position as a general theoretical phenomenon). Nizhnii Novgorod, 2003, 132 p.
16. Vlasenko N.A. Pravovye pozitsii: ponyatie i vidy (Legal positions: notion and types), Zhurnal rossiiskogo prava, 2008, No. 12.
17. Stepankov V.G. Pravovaya pozitsiya: obshcheteoreticheskie i prikladnye aspekty (Legal position: general theoretical and applied aspects). Nizhnii Novgorod, 2003, 31 p.
18. Perelman Ch. Justice, law, and argument: essays on moral and legal reasoning. Dordrecht, 1980, 181 p.
Citation :
Type of article : The scientific article
