скачать PDF
Authors : 1. Anas G. Gataullin,
doctor of law, professor
Kazan (Volga) Federal University, Kazan, Russia
2. Dinar R. Zainutdinov,
senior lecturer
Institute for Social and Humanitarian Knowledge, Kazan, Russia
«White» Russia: the problem of choice of forms of territorial organisation
Objective: to determine the «white» statehood landmark in choosing the forms of territorial organization of Russia.
Methods: the methodological basis of the research is universal dialectic method of cognition, which allows to study the phenomena and processes in their historical development based on scientific (systemic-structural), special (hermeneutics) and private law (comparative and formal legal) methods.
Results: basing on the analysis of historical analogues developed and justified in the general theory of law and state, it is proved that the state and legal ideology of «white» statehood has elaborated a direction for the construction of a complex decentralized unitary state, consisting of national-cultural and territorial autonomies.
Scientific novelty: the article develops and introduces into scientific circulation the conceptual theoretical and legal provision of regional state as one of the forms of Russia’s territorial organization, selected by «white» modes. The liberal-democratic ideology of «white» statehood in state legal construction facilitated the formation of a unitary decentralized state with wide powers of territorial and national-cultural autonomies. Centralization of power was necessary to eliminate the country's collapse. In the late period of «white» statehood (rule of P. N. Wrangel) it was supposed to build the regional state with a strong decentralization of power.
Practical value: the provisions and conclusions can be taken into account (referring to the historical experience) for the state-legal ideology formation, in case it is necessary to increase the role and influence of society in the legal and political life of the country. The research results can be used in the preparation of courses, textbooks and educational-methodical manuals, programs of the theory of state and law, history of state and law, history of political and legal doctrines, and also general courses on politics and history of Russia of XX century.
Keywords :
white statehood; unitary state; regional economy; decentralization; state legal ideology
Bibliography :
1. Gutorov, V.A Politologiya (problemy teorii) (Politology (issues of theory)). Saint-Petersburg: Lan', 2000, 384 p.
2. Rybakov, V.A. K voprosu o roli ideologii v sovremennom gosudarstve (On the issue of the role of ideology in the modern state). Vestnik Omskogo un-ta, 1998, vol. 1, pp. 91–93.
3. Tsakanyan, G.N. Belaya vlast' Yuga Rossii i antibol'shevistskie politicheskie partii i organizatsii v 1918–1920 gg.: dis. … kand. ist. nauk (White power in the South of Russia and anti-bolshevik political parties and organizations in 1918–1920). Pyatigorsk: Pyatigorskii gos. tekhnol. un-t, 2004, 165 p.
4. Kulakov, V.V. Istoriya voennogo i gosudarstvennogo stroitel'stva belykh vlastei Yuga Rossii (1917–1920 gg.): dis. … d-ra ist. nauk (History of the military and state formation of the white powers in the South of Russia (1917–1920)). Moscow: Moskovskii gos. un-t im. M.V. Lomonosova, 2005, 364 p.
5. Yakovlev, A.V. Politicheskaya i sotsial'no-ekonomicheskaya deyatel'nost' belogo dvizheniya v period Grazhdanskoi voiny v Rossii (1918–1920): dis. … kand. ist. nauk (Political and social-economic activity of the white movement during the Civil war in Russia (1918–1920)). Moscow: GOU VPO Rossiiskii un-t druzhby narodov, 2009, 193 p.
6. Nikitin, A.N. Gosudarstvennost' «beloi» Rossii: stanovlenie, evolyutsiya, krushenie (Statehood of «white» Russia: formation, evolution, collapse). Moscow: Pravo i zakon, 2004, 448 s.
7. Barsenkov, A.S. Istoriya Rossii. 1917–2009 (History of Russia. 1917–2009). Moscow: Aspekt Press, 2010, 846 p.
8. Denikin, A.I. Ocherki russkoi smuty (Sketches of the Russian riot). Berlin: Mednyi vsadnik, 1926, vol. 5, 371 p.
9. Molchanov, L.A. «Sobstvennymi rukami svoimi my rasterzali na klochki nashe gosudarstvo»: K istorii antibol'shevistskoi gosudarstvennosti perioda Grazhdanskoi voiny (1918–1920 gg.) («We have ruined our state with our hands» On the history of anti-bolshevik state during the Civil war (1918–1920)). Moscow: Posev, 2007, 207 p.
10. Tsvetkov, V.Zh. Beloe delo v Rossii. 1919 g. (formirovanie i evolyutsiya politicheskikh struktur Belogo dvizheniya v Rossii) (White activity in Russia. 1919 (formation and evolution of political structures of the white movement in Russia)). Moscow, 2009, 636 p.
11. Malinov, A.V. Filosofiya i ideologiya oblastnichestva (Philosophy and ideology of oblast authority). Saint-Petersburg: Inter-sotsis, 2012, 128 p.
12. Bagautdinov, R.O. Uchastie bashkir v Belom dvizhenii (1917–1920 gg.): dis. … kand. ist. nauk (Participation of the Bashkirs in White movement (1917–1920)). Ufa: Bashkirskii gos. un-t, 2007, 225 p.
13. Plotnikov, I.F. Aleksandr Vasil'evich Kolchak: issledovatel', admiral, Verkhovnyi pravitel' Rossii (Aleksandr Vasilyevich Kolchak: researcher, admiral, Supreme ruler of Russia). Moscow: Tsentrpoligraf, 2003, 702 p.
14. Krasnov, P.N. Vsevelikoe voisko Donskoe (All-great army of Don). Arkhiv russkoi revolyutsii. Berlin, 1922, vol. 5, 365 p.
15. Zimina, V.D. Beloe delo vzbuntovavsheisya Rossii: politicheskie rezhimy Grazhdanskoi voiny. 1917-1920 gg. (White activity of the revolting Russia: political regimes of the Civil war. 1917-1920) Moscow: Rossiiskii gumanit. un-t, 2006, 467 p.
16. Ivanets, G.I., Kalinskii, I.V., Chervonyuk, V.I. Konstitutsionnoe pravo Rossii: entsikl. slovar' (Constitutional law of Russia: encyclopedic dictionary), Moscow: Yurid. lit., 2002, 432 p.
17. Il'in, I.A. Nashi zadachi. Stat'i 1948–1954 gg.: v 2-kh t. (Our challenges. Articles of 1948–1954: in 2 vol). Moscow: Airis-press, 2008, vol. 1, 528 p.
18. Tsvetkov, V.Zh. General-leitenant, baron P. N. Vrangel' (Lieutenant General, baron P. N. Wrangel). Moscow: Astrel': AST, 2006, 446 p.
19. Vrangel', P.N. Vospominaniya 1916–1920 gg.: v 2-kh ch. (Memoirs of 1916–1920: in 2 parts). Moscow: Tsentrpoligraf, 2006, 783 p.
20. Khvostov, V.M. Avtonomiya (Autonomy). Rad'ko, T.N. Khrestomatiya po teorii gosudarstva i prava (Chrestomathy on the theory of state and law). Moscow: Prospekt, 2014, 720 p.
Citation :
