скачать PDF
Authors : 1. Victoria V. Chistyakova,
post-graduate student
Kazan (Volga) Federal University, Kazan, Russia
On the issue of guilt of the victim in liabilities for doing harm by a motor vehicle
Objective: to study of the concept of "guilt of the victim" in non-contractual obligations.
Methods: a methodological basis of the research was interdisciplinary and private scientific methods of cognition: analysis, synthesis, comparative legal, formal legal methods.
Results: basing on the analysis of pre-revolutionary, Soviet legal heritage and current legislation, the concept of "guilt" in the civil law is studied, primarily the guilt of the victim in the obligations of injury by a motor vehicle; the dynamics of views on the concept of "guilt" in the civil law doctrine is shown, as well as in the legislation of different historical periods.
Scientific novelty: the issue of the concept and value of fault of the victim in the obligations of injury done by a motor vehicle is comprehensively investigated. Subject to the provisions of the pre-revolutionary, Soviet and current legislation, and viewpoints expressed in the Russian legal science, the concept of “guilt of the victim" is explored, as well as its form, the conclusion is made about the necessity of establishing the clearly defined concepts of guilt and its forms in civil legislation.
Practical value: the theoretical provisions formulated in the study are relevant for the development of the doctrine of the guilt of the victim in tort obligations and may be used in further studies, as well as for the improvement of legislation in this sphere.
Keywords :
tort; obligation of harm; a motor vehicle; harm; guilt; form of guilt; intention; gross negligence
Bibliography :
1. Sobchak, A.A. Grazhdansko-pravovaya otvetstvennost' za prichinenie vreda deistviem istochnika povyshennoi opasnosti: avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk (Civil-legal liability for doing harm by a source of increased danger: PhD (Law) thesis). Leningrad, 1964, 15 p.
2. Konyaev, N.I. Obyazatel'stva, voznikayushchie vsledstvie prichineniya vreda istochnikom povyshennoi opasnosti: avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk (Liabilities occurring due to doing harm by a source of increased danger: abstract of PhD (Law) thesis). Moscow, 1966, 16 p.
3. Antimonov, B.S. Grazhdanskaya otvetstvennost' za vred, prichinennyi istochnikom povyshennoi opasnosti (Civil liability for harm done by a source of increased danger). Moscow: Gosyurizdat, 1952, 296 p.
4. Nefed'ev, E.A. Uchenie ob iske (Doctrine on lawsuits). Uchenye zapiski Kazanskogo universiteta, 1895, vol. 62, b. 3, pp. 77–98.
5. Sundurov, F.R. Ugolovnoe pravo Rossii (Criminal law of Russia). Kazan': Izd-vo Kazanskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, 2007, 660 p.
6. Romanov, V.V. Yuridicheskaya psikhologiya: uchebnik (Juridical psychology: textbook). Moscow: Yurist, 2006, 588 p.
7. Shershenevich, G.F. Obshchaya teoriya prava: vypusk tretii (Genarl theory of law: issue three). Moscow: Izda-nie Br. Bashmakovykh, 1912, 698 p.
8. Pirvits, E.E. Znachenie viny v grazhdanskom prave (Meaning of guilt in civil law). Zhurnal Ministerstva Yustitsii, 1895, no. 3, p. 154.
9. Simolin, A.A. Osnovaniya grazhdanskoi otvetstvennosti za vred i ubytki (Bases of civil liability for harm and losses). Kazan': Tipolitografiya Imperatorskogo Universiteta, 1905, 18 p.
10. Yablochkov, T.M. Vliyanie viny poterpevshego na razmer vozmeshchae-mykh emu ubytkov. Tom pervyi. Chast' teoreticheskaya (Influence of the guilt of victim on the size of reimbursement for their losses. Vol.1. Theoretical part). Yaroslavl': Tipografiya Gubernskogo Pravleniya, 1910, 471 p.
11. Tyutryumov, I.M. Zakony grazhdanskie. Tom pervyi (Civil laws. Vol. 1). Petrograd: iz-danie yuridicheskogo knizhnogo magazina I.I. Zubkova «Zakonove-denie», tipografiya I.I. Zubkova, 1915, 1430 p.
12. Yablochkov, T.M. Smeshannaya vina i st. 683 t. X ch. 1 [k voprosu ob yuridicheskoi prirode otvetstvennosti vladel'tsev zheleznodorozh-nykh i parokhodnykh predpriyatii po st. 683 t. X ch. 1]. Kritiko-dogmaticheskoe issledovanie (Mixed guilt and Article 683, vol.10, part 1 [on the issue of juridical nature of liability of railway and steamship companies according to Article 683, vol.10, part 1]. Critical-dogmatic research). Yaroslavl': tipografiya Gubernskogo pravleniya, 1910, 225 p.
13. Ioffe, O.S. Obyazatel'stva po vozmeshcheniyu vreda (Liabilities for damage reimbursement). Leningrad: Izd-vo Leningradskogo gosudarstvennogo Ordena Lenina universiteta im. A.A. Zhdanova, 1952, 127 p.
14. Agarkov, M.M. Vina poterpevshego v obyazatel'stvakh iz prichineniya vreda (Guilt of the victim in liabilities due to inflicting damage). Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo, 1940, no. 3, pp. 70–79.
15. Fonoberov, L.V. Osobennosti kategorii viny v obyazatel'stvakh vsledstvie prichineniya vreda: avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk (Features of guilt category in liabilities due to inflicting damage: abstract of PhD (Law) thesis). Moscow, 2010, 29 p.
16. Braginskii, M.I., Vitryanskii, V.V. Dogovornoe pravo. Kniga pervaya: obshchie polozheniya (Contract law. Book 1: general provisions). Moscow: Statut, 2008, 847 p.
Citation :
