по-русски

Actual Problems of
Economics and Law

 

16+

 

DOI: 10.21202/1993-047X.14.2020.3.545-557

скачать PDF

Authors :
1. Ekaterina B. Abakumova, PhD (Law), Researcher of the Department of Social and Legal Research; Associate Professor of the Department of Civil Law
Institute of Philosophy of the Siberian branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences; Novosibirsk Military Institute named after General I. K. Yakovlev of the National Guard of the Russian Federation



Bad faith and unreasonableness as grounds for civil-legal liability of a person functioning as a sole executive body of an economic entity


Objective: theoretical and legal analysis of the application of the legal categories of good faith and reasonableness in judicial practice on corporate disputes related to bringing directors of companies to civil liability.
 
Methods: the work used general (system approach, analysis, synthesis, induction, deduction) and special legal (formal legal, comparative legal) methods.
 
Results: based on the study of the Russian legislation and law enforcement practice, the article analyzes the theoretical and practical issues of bringing to civil liability the heads of enterprises for losses caused to the company as a result of unfair or unreasonable actions committed by them. The paper focuses on the foreign experience in the field under study and reveals the relationship of the Russian terms “good faith” and “reasonableness” with the fiduciary duty of a manager to be loyal to the corporation and to take due care of the owner’s interests.
 
Scientific novelty: the author reveals the theoretical and legal meaning of the concepts of “good faith” and “reasonableness” in corporate relations, which does not coincide with the general civil understanding of these legal categories. The paper substantiates the fundamental importance of determining the legal meaning of the term “interests of a legal entity” for judicial practice in cases of bringing to justice persons who perform the functions of executive bodies of business entities. The article proposes to set out Part 3 of Article 53 of the Russian Civil Code as follows: “a person, by virtue of the law or any other legal act or constitutive documents of the legal entity, authorized to act on its behalf must act in accordance with the objectives and interests of the legal entity they represent, reasonably and in good faith”. This clarification assumedly will reduce the uncertainty in conflict situations that arise regarding the assessment of the director’s actions compliance with the legal entity interests. This wording clearly shows that, regardless of the current interests of the business entity expressed, for example, by the general meeting of participants, the director should first of all be guided by the goals of the legal entity
when making any decision.
 
Practical significance: the main provisions and conclusions of the work can be used in scientific, pedagogical and law enforcement activities when considering issues related to the civil liability of directors in cases where their actions require correlation with the legal entity interests.

Keywords :
Civil law; Good faith; Reasonableness; Interests of a legal entity; Corporate relations; Fiduciary duties; Due diligence; Conflict of interest; Civil liability of the director; Compensation for losses; Reasonable business risks

Bibliography :
1. Filippova S., Shitkina I. Commercial legal persons: doctrinal, legislative and practical aspects of improving the legislation on organizational-legal forms of juridical persons, Khozyaistvo i pravo, 2019, No. 2, pp. 3–20 (in Russ.).
2. Stepanov D. I., Mikhal'chuk Yu. S. Judicial practice for liability of a director to a corporation for incurred damages, Vestnik ekonomicheskogo pravosudiya RF, 2018, No. 4, pp. 8–63 (in Russ.).
3. Artemenkov V. K. A juridical person’s body as a legal means, Aktual'nye problemy rossiiskogo prava, 2016, No. 10 (71), pp. 84–93 (in Russ.).
4. Konovalov A. V. Good faith principle in the new edition of the Russian Civil Code and in judicial practice, Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshei shkoly ekonomiki, 2016, No. 4, pp. 4–14 (in Russ.).
5. Leskova Yu. G., Zhukova Yu. D., Pavlova K. P. Civil-legal liability of the management members of economic entities: trends in the Russian legislation development and foreign experience, Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Yuridicheskie nauki, 2018, Is. 40, pp. 264–289 (in Russ.).
6. Gutnikov O. V. Grounds for developing the category of corporate liability in civil law, Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshei shkoly ekonomiki, 2019, No. 4, pp. 4–30 (in Russ.).
7. Lutsenko S. I. Fiduciary rules of the game and the essence of management in a company, Strategicheskie resheniya i riskmenedzhment, 2019, No. 2, pp. 144–155 (in Russ.).
8. Lutsenko S. I. Directorate versus owners: cognitive dissonance or balance of interests between the company participants, Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshei shkoly ekonomiki, 2015, No. 1, pp. 194–207 (in Russ.).
9. Miller P. B. Justifying Fiduciary Duties, McGill Law Journal, 2013, Vol. 58, available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2083855 (access date: 20.05.2020).
10. Bohinc R. Conflicts of directors interests with the interests of the company in the context of financial and economic crisis (a comparative overview of some EU countries), available at: https://www.virtusinterpress.org/IMG/pdf/CONFLICTS_OF_DIRECTORS_INTERESTS_WITH_THE_INTERESTS_OF_THE_COMPANY_IN_THE_CONTEX_OF_FINANCIAL_AND_
ECONOMIC_CRISIS_a_comparative_overview_of_some_EU_countries_by_Rado_Bohinc.pdf (access date: 20.05.2020).
11. Zhukova Yu. D., Pirogova E. S. Standards of a good faith and reasonable behavior of a head of an economic entity in the modern legislation and judicial practice: disputable issues of forming the criteria of lawful behavior, Vlast' zakona, 2014, No. 4, pp. 93–114.
12. Budylin S. L. Duties of fiduciaries in fundamental deals: American experience, Zakon, 2019, No. 1, pp. 65–79 (in Russ.).
13. Pugachev N. S. Global genesis of the institution of liability of management bodies of juridical persons, Zakon i pravo, 2020, No. 1, pp. 72–76 (in Russ.).
14. Abakumova E. B. Good faith principle in private law: issues of theory, legislation and practice, Sovremennoe pravo, 2017, No. 8, pp. 44–49 (in Russ.).
15. Brisov Yu. V. Liability of an executive body of a juridical body for bad faith actions, Aktual'nye problemy rossiiskogo prava, 2019, No. 9 (106), pp. 174–184 (in Russ.).
16. Bushev A. Yu. On the freedom of business decisions making and legal criteria for defining its limits: the criterion of clear obviousness, Arbitrazhnye spory, 2013, No. 3, pp. 113–132 (in Russ.).
17. Klyuchareva E. M. The rule of protecting a business decision in cases on directors’ liability: legislation and practice of Delaware state (USA), Germany and Russia, Zakon, 2015, No. 11, pp. 132–141 (in Russ.).
18. Popondopulo V. F., Petrov D. A. Compliance as a legal tool for risks minimization and crime prevention, Vestnik SPbGU, Ser. 14, Pravo, 2020, No. 1, pp. 102–114 (in Russ.).
19. Inshakova A. O., Turbina I. A. New policy of liability of a sole executive body of an economic entity for making an unprofitable deal, Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Yuridicheskie nauki, 2014, No. 4, pp. 119–127 (in Russ.).
20. Nazarova E. N. Civil-legal liability of the members of management bodies of economic entities: PhD (Law) thesis, Ekaterinburg, 2015. 212 p. (in Russ.).
21. Gabov A. V. On liability of the members of management bodies of juridical persons, Vestnik VAS RF, 2013, No. 7, pp. 36–79 (in Russ.).
22. Stepanov D. I. Interests of a juridical person and its participants, Vestnik ekonomicheskogo pravosudiya RF, 2015, No. 1, pp. 29–83 (in Russ.).
23. Korchagin A. G., Chertorinskii E. A. Interest of a juridical person as a means of protecting the rights of shareholders, Aktual'nye problemy rossiiskogo prava, 2014, No. 8, pp. 1664–1672 (in Russ.).

Citation :
Abakumova E. B. Bad faith and unreasonableness as grounds for civil-legal liability of a person functioning as a sole executive body of an economic entity, Actual Problems of Economics and Law, 2020, Vol. 14, No. 3, pp. 545–557 (in Russ.). DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.21202/1993-047X.14.2020.3.545-557

Type of article : The scientific article

Date of receipt of the article :
01.06.2020

Date of adoption of the print :
10.07.2020

Date of online accommodation :
25.09.2020